'Home rule' supporters push to expand local government authority in Virginia ahead of General Assembly session

A new effort would change how local authority is decided in Virginia, moving away from the century-old Dillon's Rule that limits what counties, cities and towns can do.
'Home rule' supporters push to expand local government authority in Virginia
Add WTVR as a Google Preferred Source

RICHMOND, Va. — For more than a century, "Dillon's Rule" has defined the relationship between Virginia's local and state governments.

The legal doctrine stems from an Iowa Supreme Court case in the late 1870s, and according to the Virginia State Senate website, the rule limits what counties, cities and towns can do without first getting permission from the Virginia General Assembly.

Now, with the next General Assembly session approaching at the start of the new year, supporters of changing the rule are sharing their reasons why.

Mariah Robalino, with the Virginia Home Rule Project, held a webinar Monday alongside Virginia lawmakers, community leaders and policy experts to preview new legislation they believe could help Virginians statewide.

"Virginia's communities deserve the power to solve their own problems," Robalino said.
"Our campaign is advancing home rule, a modern approach that gives local governments greater authority to respond to local needs while preserving strong statewide protections," Robalino said.

Supporters called the current restrictions under Dillon's Rule archaic and not what's best for localities.

Bruce McDonald, director of the Municipal Research Lab at Old Dominion University, pointed to research on how the rule affects local decision-making.

"And perhaps the most striking finding was this. More than 50% reported that their locality had modified or abandoned a potential policy because they anticipated state preemption. Think about what that means. We're not just talking about local proposals that were debated and rejected. We're talking about ideas that may never have reached a public discussion because officials believe they lack the authority to pursue them," McDonald said.

Christian Martinez, with CASA, said those limits can have real consequences, claiming it to be especially harmful for families struggling with rising rent.

"So right now when these families go to their city councils or county board of supervisors for help, they are met with the same frustrating answers, which is our hands are just tied. That's why we at CASA are calling on Virginia to become a home rule state. Home rule is a simple common sense principle that local communities should have the power to solve local problems," Martinez said.

Democratic Delegate Fernando Martinez is championing the Virginia Home Rule Act, and he said the act would flip the way local authority is decided, giving localities more room to act unless the state has specifically limited or prohibited it.

"That is why I'm proud to introduce the Virginia Home Rule Act. Our bill makes one fundamental change. Instead of asking whether Richmond gives the community permission to act, we would ask, has the commonwealth prohibited or limited that community from acting?" Martinez said.

"And let me make this really clear, this does not take away the General Assembly's ultimate authority. Strong statewide protections remain," Martinez said.

The bill is still under review and has not yet been formally introduced.

CBS 6 also reached out to Republican state leaders and is still waiting to hear back.

CBS 6 is committed to sharing community voices on this important topic. Email your thoughts to the CBS 6 Newsroom.

  • This story was initially reported by a journalist and has been converted to this platform with the assistance of AI. Our editorial team verifies all reporting on all platforms for fairness and accuracy. To learn more about how we use AI in our newsroom, click here.