Where Brat and Spanberger differ on immigration and health care

Posted at 3:39 PM, Oct 16, 2018
and last updated 2018-10-16 15:39:54-04

CULPEPER, Va. -- Rep. Dave Brat (R - 7th District) and his Democratic challenger Abigail Spanberger drew sharp contrasts in Culpeper on Monday evening at their only scheduled debate. The candidates, who are in a nationally-watched tight race in Virginia’s 7th district, discussed their positions on a multitude of issues, such as student debt reform, climate change, and the housing crises. But the two most pressing topics brought up were immigration and healthcare.


In his opening remarks, Brat said that he has always been a leader on immigration reform and that he has achieved results. He added that even though he was elected just four years ago he already helped to halt a “liberal amnesty bill” in Congress, which would have been “devastating for Virginia wages and for Virginia jobs.”

“We’ve achieved a huge result by avoiding amnesty bills,” Brat said.

He also cited recent congressional efforts to pass an immigration bill, which failed to gain support in the House of Representatives.

Rep. Dave Brat

“Every major Democrat, including Barbara Jordan, the great civil rights leader, was in favor of all the components in that Goodlatte bill,” Brat said. “If you look at the facts of the matter, it’s very clear that my opponent falls to the very far left on this issue of immigration.”

Brat also criticized Spanberger for supporting sanctuary cities, which he accused of disregarding federal law enforcement and the “laws of the land.”

Spanberger defended her stance on sanctuary cities in Virginia, citing her previous work with federal ICE agents and drug trafficking task forces.

“I am well aware of the role of federal agents. I do not support safe-havens for criminals or gangs. I do not support anything that would make our community weak,” said Spanberger, who is former CIA officer. “I used to work every single day to keep the community I lived in safe, and to keep our communities free of drugs on the street.”

Abigail Spanberger

Spanberger said that her stance on immigration is that there needs to be “comprehensive, bipartisan immigration reform,” which the country has not seen yet. “We need comprehensive immigration reform that is strong on border security and strengthening our points of entry,” she added. “But we also need immigration reform that will meet the needs of our employers here throughout the 7th district and gives certainty to Dreamers.”

Health Care

Immigration policy wasn’t the only topic Spanberger and Brat disagreed on during the forum. Both candidates had much to say about health care and its impact on the 7th district. Brat said that more competition is needed to lower the high costs of prescription medication.

“For a free market to thrive, we need a large number of small firms competing against each other,” he said. “These drugs are vitally needed and we need low-cost drugs. So, the basic idea is to return power back to the states and localities.”

Brat claimed that Spanberger’s support of the “Medicare for All” plan, which would make medicare the basis for all health insurance in the country, would also raise healthcare costs substantially. “The way to lower prices is to get rid of Obamacare,” Brat said.

But Spanberger said she actually disagreed with the plan and advocated for the “Medicare-X Choice Act” instead. It extends the option of Medicare to non-elderly Americans.

This was an extremely important distinction to constituents in the 7th district, like resident Karen Whitacre.

“My family actually received our healthcare through the ACA,” she said. Whitacre said Brat’s opposition to affordable health insurance and coverage of pre-existing conditions was a major concern to her family, and she felt her needs weren’t being listened to.

“When Spanberger announced her candidacy, I really knew that she was someone that would listen to our concerns and act on them in Congress, which Dave Brat has not been able to do,” Whitacre said.

Some residents, like tree farm owner Kurt Christensen, argued Spanberger’s approach would be more detrimental to rural voters.

He said that Brat has been one of rural Virginia’s “great champions,” and that “Dave Brat’s philosophy of limited government, the constitution and less government spending is good for my business.”

The forum in Culpeper will likely remain the only debate in the 7th district race.

By Rachel Kidwell and Taylor Mills (Special to

EDITOR’S NOTE: has partnered with the “iPadJournos” mobile and social media journalism project at VCU’s Richard T. Robertson School of Media and Culture. Students from the project reported this story.



Watch 'The Jennifer Hudson Show' weekdays at 3 p.m. on CBS 6!

📱 Download CBS 6 News App
The app features breaking news alerts, live video, weather radar, traffic incidents, closings and delays and more.